Federal Court of Appeal upholds Federal Court’s summary trial finding of patent invalidity
Background The Federal Court of Appeal has rarely upheld or granted a finding of invalidity in the context of a summary trial;...Read More
Preventous et al. still unsuccessful in accessing information to support their judicial review
The Federal Court of Appeal continues to decline the efforts of three private health clinics to obtain information from Health Canada to...Read More
A tale of two DRAGONAS
This case involves two related companies that had been using the same trademark based on an informal understanding. After many years of...Read More
Court of Appeal Clarifies Costs Framework in Copyright Class Action
On November 15, 2017, the Federal Court of Appeal issued its Reasons for Judgment in an appeal from an order that (1)...Read More
Subject Matter Of A Compound Claim Cannot Be Expanded Beyond What It States – FCA
On September 18, 2017, the Federal Court of Appeal released its decision in BMS’ appeal of a decision dismissing its prohibition application...Read More
U-Box It Knocks Out U-Haul’s Confusing Trademark Applications
U Box It, a Canadian company providing garbage removal and waste management services, is the registered owner of the Canadian trademark U...Read More
Without Early Working, Cross-Referenced Drug Submissions Need Not Address Listed Patents: Court of Appeal
On October 12, 2016 the Federal Court of Appeal released a number of judgments dealing with the circumstances in which a cross-referenced...Read More
Trial Judges Entitled To Some “Leeway” On Construction
On September 6, 2016, the Court of Appeal dismissed Nova Chemicals Corporations appeal from a judgment finding its SURPASS product infringes Canadian...Read More
Punitive Damages May Exceed Compensatory Damages: Federal Court of Appeal
The Federal Court of Appeal has agreed that, in principle, an award for punitive damages may exceed compensatory damages. In Annie Pui...Read More
Preliminary Determinations Restricted to Pure Questions of Law – Federal Court of Appeal
In Rogers Communication Partnership et al v. Society of Composers, Authors and Music Publishers of Canada, 2016 FCA 28, the Federal Court...Read More
Failure to Disclose Public Servant Status Will Not Void a Patent
On February 5, 2016 Justice Boivin (writing on behalf of the Court of Appeal) released the reasons for judgment in Brown v....Read More
Un-Metatag Me! Copying metags found non-infringing by FCA
In Red Label Vacations Inc. v. 411 Travel Buys Ltd., 2015 FCA 290, the Federal Court of Appeal upheld a decision of...Read More
A Confluence of Two Streams – Subsequent Amalgamation Cannot Change Contracting Parties’ Intention
In April 2009, Pfizer and ratiopharm settled a prohibition application under the PM(NOC) Regulations in respect of the drug product ratio-sildenafil. Subsequent...Read More
What does that patent say, anyway? Appellate review of patent construction
In two recent judgments, Cobalt v. Bayer and ABB v Hyundai, the Federal Court of Appeal has explicitly considered the appropriate standard of review for...Read More
A Sheep In Wolf’s Clothing – Alleged Errors of Fact Should Not Be Dressed Up As Errors Of Law
The Federal Court of Appeal recently considered two competing appeals regarding patents listed on the Patent Register against Alcon’s moxifloxacin product, VIGAMOX....Read More
Court of Appeal Is Not The Place to Reargue Factual Findings
On September 16, 2015, the Federal Court of Appeal dismissed Actavis’s appeal from a judgment of the Federal Court prohibiting the Minister...Read More
FCA Upholds the “Reasonably Diligent Search” Standard, For Now
The Federal Court of Appeal in E. Mishan & Sons, Inc. v. Supertek Canada Inc., 2015 FCA 163, dismissed an appeal from...Read More
Inventive concept need not be coterminous with promised utility
On July 6, 2015 the Federal Court of Appeal released it decision on AstraZeneca’s appeal of Justice Rennie’s decision holding that the...Read More
Sound Prediction: Self-evident Elements Need Not Be Explicitly Disclosed
On June 3, 2015, the Federal Court of Appeal held that elements that would be self-evident to the skilled person need not...Read More
Court of Appeal primes Supreme Court of Canada to revisit appellate review of claim construction and prohibition against methods of medical treatment
On May 4, 2015, the Federal Court of Appeal released its Reasons for Judgment in an appeal in a prohibition application involving...Read More
Relief or Relapse? Federal Court of Appeal orders re-trial of STELARA infringement case
The Federal Court of Appeal has remitted the infringement and validity action regarding AbbVie’s Canadian Patent No. 2,365,281 and Janssen’s drug STELARA...Read More
Wrongly issued COMBIGAN prohibition order upheld for different reasons
On November 23, 2012, the Federal Court of Appeal dismissed Apotex’s appeal of Justice Hughes’ Judgment granting a prohibition Order in respect...Read More