Equitable Remedies not in the Program for Rovi Guides
The Federal Court ruled on the availability of equitable remedies, namely an an accounting for profits and injunctive relief under s. 57(1)... Read More
Overbreadth is in the Eye of the Beholder – The Federal Court’s Overbreadth Analysis in Rovi #2
As reported in our recent post here, the Federal Court invalidated the claims of four patents asserted by Rovi Guides, Inc. and... Read More
Federal Court takes Rovi’s IPTV patents off the air
Justice Lafrenière dismissed Rovi’s infringement actions and granted the defendants’ counterclaims for declarations of invalidity, holding that nothing in the asserted claims... Read More
Infringers held accountable with the springboard profits and accounting for profits remedies
The SCC dismissed Nova Chemical’s appeal of Dow Chemicals’ accounting of profits and springboard profits award in an 8:1 (Côté J. dissenting)... Read More
Costs Awarded on Appeal Clarifying FC Model Protective Order
Justice Go recently released her costs order and reasons arising from Surewerx USA Inc. v. Dentec Safety Specialists Inc., 2022 FC 1190.... Read More
Dishwasher Detergent Pod Case Deserves “Full Cycle” of Trial: “Express Wash” Summary Judgment Rejected by Court of Appeal
In GEMAK v Jempak, the Federal Court of Appeal set aside a decision granting summary judgment and directed that the matter proceed... Read More
One-sided assessment of prejudice undermines decision regarding amendment of trademark Statement of Opposition
In Anheuser Busch LLC v H.O.W. Medical Solutions Ltd., 2022 FC 842, Justice Walker set aside a decision by the Trademarks Opposition... Read More
Strike Two: CIPO’s Problem Has a Solution
The Canadian Intellectual Property Office has taken another hit in Benjamin Moore in which two decisions of the Commissioner of Patents rejecting... Read More
Burden on summary trial can shift, and both parties come up short on ownership
In Mud Engineering Inc. v Secure Energy (Drilling Services) Inc., 2022 FC 943, Justice St-Louis dismissed a motion for summary trial and... Read More
Federal Court clarifies test for Protective Orders with Counsel’s Eyes Only Provisions
In Del Ridge Homes Inc. v Ledgemark Homes Inc., 2022 FC 566 the Federal Court upheld Prothonotary Milczynski’s decision to dismiss Ledgemark... Read More
Disproportional Damage Amounts Claimed are Abusive and May Cost a Claimant
In a recent patent and defamation case, the Québec Superior Court denied damages that were unsupported by evidence and which lacked a... Read More
BC Civil Resolution Tribunal Restates the Ingredients of a Binding Settlement Agreement
Background In the underlying dispute, Ehsan Haji Mahdizadeh Zargar alleged that the City of Vancouver infringed his copyright in 2 photographs by... Read More
Everyone Gets a Slice, But No One Controls the Milano Pizzeria Trademark
The Federal Court has expunged Milano Pizza Ltd’s Canadian Trademark Registration TMA571,114 for MILANO PIZZERIA & Design: Milano Lost Control of Its... Read More
Federal Court Clarifies Law on Arbitration Clauses
In General Entertainment and Music Inc. v. Gold Line Telemanagement Inc., 2022 FC 418, the Federal Court clarified the legal test applicable... Read More
Federal Court Addresses the Hallmarks of Unregistrable, Laudatory Trademarks
Rick Spagnuolo and Joseph Syposz (the “Opponents”) opposed Re/Max’s application to register “HALLMARK” in association with real estate services. The Trademarks Opposition... Read More
The Price of Contempt
In August 2018, Justice Patillo granted summary judgment (see here) permitting recognition and enforcement in Ontario of US judgments against the defendants,... Read More
A fair trial, not a perfect trial: SCC provides guidance on the limits of judicial intervention during a cross-examination
A majority of the SCC has affirmed a decision that a trial judge’s rulings curtailing lines of questioning in a cross-examination in... Read More
Concession Counters Apple’s Bifurcation Motion in Battle over Standards Essential Patent
Wi-Lan sued Apple, and sought an injunction, claiming that several Apple products which comply with the 4G and 5G standards necessarily infringe... Read More
No Evidence of Use Puts Trademark Owner in Hot Water
APEC sold reverse osmosis drinking water filtration systems under the business name “APEC Water Systems” for over 20 years, making its first... Read More
Action against whistle-tweeting – not a SLAPP says Court
In Proctorio, Incorporated v Linkletter, 2022 BCSC 400, the Supreme Court of British Columbia dismissed an application under s 4 of the... Read More
In Summary, A Foreign Voluntary Dismissal is not Res Judicata
Defendant Sonos, Inc brought a summary judgment motion to dismiss Google LLC’s Canadian patent infringement action. The parties had agreed to a... Read More
Copyright Style Tips from the USSC: Knowledge is the New Colour
Suppose that John, seeing a flash of red in a tree, says, “There is a cardinal.” But he is wrong. The bird... Read More
Trademark Must-Haves: Clean Underwear and Supporting Evidence
Fruit of the Loom successfully appealed a decision from the Registrar of Trademarks finding no likelihood of confusion between its registered mark,... Read More
Lululemon “high quality replicas” result in a tight bind
The Federal Court reviewed first principles applicable to remedies for trademark infringement for counterfeit goods in an uncontested summary trial. The defendants... Read More
Federal Circuit Applies On-Sale Bar to Offer for Sale of Catheter Introducer
The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has reversed the decision of the US District Court for the Eastern... Read More